Judgment Proof vs Bankruptcy: Making the Right Choice for Your Financial Future

Are you drowning in debt, facing a lawsuit, and worried about losing everything? The terms “judgment proof and bankruptcy” might be swirling around your head, leaving you feeling lost and overwhelmed. It’s a stressful situation to be in, and you’re not alone. But what exactly do these terms mean, and how can understanding them help you navigate this challenging time?

What Does It Mean to Be Judgment Proof?

Being “judgment proof” doesn’t mean you magically escape your debts. It means that even if a creditor wins a lawsuit against you (getting a “money judgment”), they can’t actually collect on it because you don’t have any assets they can legally take. They tagged you, but they can’t really do anything about it.

This is usually because your income and assets are “exempt” under the law. Think of things like:

  • Social Security benefits.
  • Certain retirement accounts.
  • Disability payments.
  • A portion of your wages (the exact amount varies by state).

Essentially, you’re left with enough to live on, even if you owe money. It’s important to remember that state laws vary when it comes to asset and income exemptions. For example, in New York, property that can be protected from judgment creditors includes a certain amount of equity in your home, basic household goods, necessary tools of trade, a motor vehicle up to a certain amount, personal belongings like clothes and jewelry, and most retirement accounts.

How Does Bankruptcy Fit into This?

While being judgment proof offers some protection, it’s not a perfect solution. You still have debt, and it can cast a long shadow over your financial future. That’s where bankruptcy often comes into play.

Chapter 7 Bankruptcy

This type of bankruptcy involves selling off nonexempt assets to pay off creditors. Any remaining debt is typically discharged. While this might sound scary, the good news is, many people filing for Chapter 7 don’t own many assets that aren’t exempt under bankruptcy law.

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

Here, you work out a repayment plan to address your debts over a period of three to five years. Bankruptcy is a significant decision that can heavily impact your credit score. However, if you’re judgment proof but anticipate your financial situation improving in the future, bankruptcy can protect you from aggressive debt collectors down the road.

So, Judgment Proof or Bankruptcy – What’s Right for Me?

That’s a question only YOU can answer. But here are some things to consider:

Factors Favoring Judgment Proof Status:

  • Your income is low and primarily from protected sources.
  • You don’t foresee your financial situation improving much in the future.
  • You want to avoid the more serious, long-term impact of bankruptcy on your credit.

Factors Favoring Bankruptcy:

  • You have assets you’re at risk of losing.
  • Your financial situation may improve (meaning you could become “un-judgment proof”).
  • You want a clean slate – a fresh start to rebuild your financial life without old debt hanging over your head.

Life as a Judgment Proof Individual

It’s not always easy. Even if you’re judgment proof, that doesn’t stop some creditors from trying. You might experience persistent calls or even threats of legal action. A judgment-proof life might be filled with legal challenges that can feel overwhelming and unending.

Here’s a real-life scenario. Let’s say your name is John, and you unfortunately lost your job a year ago. Unable to keep up with your mounting medical bills, you eventually find yourself being sued by a collection agency. Being unemployed, with your only source of income being government assistance, the agency manages to obtain a judgment against you. They want their money.

But with no seizable assets or garnish-able wages, you’re essentially judgment proof. This protection, however, doesn’t prevent the agency from relentlessly pursuing you – a frustrating and stressful experience. This scenario brings into sharp focus the question of judgment proof and bankruptcy. What would be the better choice for John, and how do you determine the right path for your own circumstances?

Ultimately, the decision comes down to your unique circumstances and comfort level. Speaking with a qualified bankruptcy attorney can provide much-needed clarity and guide you toward a more secure financial future.

Conclusion

Deciding whether to pursue judgment proof and bankruptcy are big decisions with lasting implications. It’s crucial to weigh your options carefully, seek expert legal counsel, and choose a path that paves the way for a brighter, debt-free tomorrow.

William Waldner is an experienced bankruptcy attorney that specializes in New York cases. He has a strong understanding of the laws and which avenues are best depending on the situation. Some of the clients Mr. Waldner meets with find that Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy is the right option for them, while others choose other avenues like credit counseling or debt consolidation. We are here to inform—you are the one to choose. Schedule your consultation today. 

Share